U.S. Supreme Court Punts on the Second Amendment

U.S. Supreme Court Punts on the Second Amendment
shutterstock.com

On April 27, 2020, the United States Supreme Court handed-down its first opinion related to the Second Amendment since McDonald v. City of Chicago (2010). Both sides are claiming victory.

New York State Rifle Association v. City of New York, was widely anticipated by gun rights advocates and was the first real hope in a decade that the new court would move the ball forward and repeal a local gun-control law. Instead, the case ended with what one publication aptly described as “a whimper”.  

The case came as a challenge to a New York City law that effectively banned firearm possession outside of the home. The law prohibited the transportation of firearms outside of the city limits, even if they were locked, unloaded and licensed. With few ranges located inside the city, the law created serious problems for New Yorkers who actually wanted to shoot their legally owned firearms. Even by New York City standards, the law was egregious.  

New York State Rifle Association, the National Rifle Association’s in-state affiliate, challenged the law in Federal District Court. New York City repealed the law in a successful effort to render the case moot. Because the law was repealed, the majority of justices agreed with that argument. “the City amended the rule so that petitioners may now transport firearms to a second home or shooting range outside of the city, which is the precise relief that petitioners requested in the prayer for relief in their complaint," the unsigned majority opinion states. That may be the headline, but there is more to the story. 


Justice Alito, long considered a strong voice for gun owners on the court, was joined by Justices Thomas and Gorsuch in a strong dissent. Alito wrote that “By incorrectly dismissing this case as moot, the Court permits our docket to be manipulated in a way that should not be countenanced…our decision in McDonald v. Chicago…established that this right is fully applicable to the States. Since then, the lower courts have decided numerous cases involving Second Amendment challenges to a variety of federal, state, and local laws. Most have failed.” Alito believes that the court should have decided on the merits of this case, instead of remanding the case back to the lower court.   


In a concurring opinion, Justice Kavanaugh echoed the arguments of the dissent. That concurring opinion contains some of the most useful clues in the entire document. “And I share Justice Alito’s concern that some federal and state courts may not be properly applying Heller and McDonald. The Court should address that issue soon, perhaps in one of the several Second Amendment cases with petitions for certiorari now pending before the Court.” Kavanaugh wrote.

Gun control groups are claiming victory, but it is clear that at least a plurality of Justices want to rule on the constitutionality of state and local gun control laws. With Justices Alito, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh and Thomas all appearing to support our second amendment rights, the swing vote appears to be Chief Justice Roberts. It is worth noting that Roberts voted with the majority in both Heller and McDonald, upholding the concept of applying the Second Amendment to the states. The moral of the story is that it takes just the right case to create meaningful precedent at this level. Heller was such a case, as was McDonald. This case was not, but our time will come. 

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Beretta

Beretta's New 92X

The 92X Performance model from Beretta was created to satisfy two requirements: Speed and accuracy. Beretta's new competition pistol is uncompromising and aims for top performance.

Black Hills Evolution of Rifle Cartridge: .308 Win. 175 Gr. Match

Black Hills Evolution of Rifle Cartridge: .308 Win. 175 Gr. Match

David Fortier talks with Jeff Hoffman of Black Hills Ammunition about the evolution of the .308 Win. 175 Gr. Match bullet.

All About .300 Blackout

All About .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout is here to stay, and we take some time to look at new technology surrounding this cartridge. Next, we pit subsonic rivals against each other before stretching the legs of this CQB round out to 600 yards from a short 9-inch barrel.

Gun Clips with Joe Mantegna - 94 WINCHESTER

Gun Clips with Joe Mantegna - 94 WINCHESTER

Joe Mantegna talks about the origins of the 94 Winchester rifle.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Check out these great options for Dad on Father's Day! Accessories

2019 Guns & Ammo Father's Day Gift Guide

G&A Digital Staff - May 07, 2019

Check out these great options for Dad on Father's Day!

Crossbreed's new The Reckoning holster is a simple leather-Kydex combination with multiple points of retention adjustment and clip options. Accessories

Crossbreed's The Reckoning Holster

Eric R. Poole - May 13, 2019

Crossbreed's new The Reckoning holster is a simple leather-Kydex combination with multiple...

The Hornady 6.5 PRC (Precision Rifle Cartridge) is a Rifle

6.5 PRC - Magnumized 6.5 Creedmoor

Tom Beckstrand - August 01, 2018

The Hornady 6.5 PRC (Precision Rifle Cartridge) is a "magnumized" 6.5 Creedmoor. It offers...

From milled slides to optics-included packages, these pistol options are all red-dot sight ready. Handguns

14 Red Dot Ready Pistols You Must See

James Tarr - December 20, 2018

From milled slides to optics-included packages, these pistol options are all red-dot sight...

See More Trending Articles

More 2nd Amendment

Virginia has always been an extremely friendly environment for gun owners since Republicans took control of the Assembly more than 20 years ago, but things have changed. 2nd Amendment

Gun Control in Virginia

Keith Wood - July 17, 2020

Virginia has always been an extremely friendly environment for gun owners since Republicans...

With the 2020 Presidential Election in the news, and the gun control versus gun rights issue on the minds of both sides of the aisle, the United States' firearm laws are again being compared to the rest of the world. How do America's firearms laws compare to those throughout the rest of the world? Read on. 2nd Amendment

International Gun Laws vs. U.S.

Guns & Ammo Staff - June 10, 2020

With the 2020 Presidential Election in the news, and the gun control versus gun rights issue...

Perspective from the National Shooting Sports Foundation.

NSSF: Atlanta Mayor Brings Gun-Control Credentials to Moms Demand Veepstakes

Larry Keane - July 24, 2020

Perspective from the National Shooting Sports Foundation.

Unless something significant happens, it is very possible that we will wake up on November 13, 2020, with a Democrat President-elect, an increased Democratic majority in the House and, if things go really bad, a Democratic majority in the Senate. 2nd Amendment

2020 Election – Worst-Case for Gun Owners

Guns & Ammo Staff - July 08, 2020

Unless something significant happens, it is very possible that we will wake up on November 13,...

See More 2nd Amendment

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now