California Magazine Ban Update

2A News: U.S. 9th Circuit Court ends California's magazine ban.

California Magazine Ban Update

On Friday, August 14, 2020, the a three-judge panel from the United States Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit released its opinion in Duncan vs. Becerra, a case that challenged California’s ban on magazines that hold more than 10 rounds. In what many considered a surprise ruling, the court declared that the ban violates the Second Amendment rights of Californians and should be struck down, granting summary judgment to Duncan. Legalese aside, it’s a big deal.  

While individual rights such as those guaranteed by the 1st, 4th and 14th Amendments to the U.S. Constitution are the litigated frequently, there is a dearth of case law regarding the Second Amendment. For example, it was nearly 70 years after the Supreme Court handed-down its decision in United States V. Miller until it revisited the topic in District of Columbia vs. Heller.

Though Heller was a generational victory for the individual right to keep and bear arms, it has not been applied by the appellate courts in a way that has repealed individual gun or magazine bans — until now. The Duncan opinion, written by Trump-appointed Judge Kenneth Lee, lays out the two-prong test that the court used to come to their decision. This is basically universal in Constitutional law cases.

The first prong is whether the law in question “burdens conduct protected by the Second Amendment.” The court ruled that the California law did represent a burden, satisfying part the first prong. Additionally, the court ruled that “Large Capacity Magazines” (“LCM” in the court’s lingo) are “protected arms under the Second Amendment” because they are commonly owned and typically used for lawful purposes, and are not “unusual arms.” Finally, Lee’s opinion stated that the ban does not enjoy “a presumption of lawfulness.”   


Though the first prong sounds great to the layperson, it is the second prong that gets lawyers excited. The second element of the test is what level of scrutiny to apply to the state law. In the past, what is called “intermediate scrutiny” has usually been applied to Second Amendment cases due to the compelling state interest of reducing gun violence. In this opinion, the court applied the “strict scrutiny” standard, which favors the rights of the individual over the desires of the government. Lee ruled that the law “struck at the core right of law-abiding citizens to self-defend” and, as a blanket ban, was not narrowly tailored to suit the state’s interests.          


Second Amendment advocates have long lamented the fact that gun rights were never given the importance of free speech rights by the courts, this time they were. If the standard in Duncan is applied to every firearm and magazine ban across the U.S., the results would be a sweeping victory for individual rights. While this is an important first step, there are more hurdles in the way.

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra will no doubt challenge the court’s decision, which means it will go before a larger en banc review. An en banc panel is composed of the Chief Judge in the Circuit along with 10 other judges, chosen at random. The Chief Judge, Sidney Thomas, is a Clinton appointee who was part of the majority in the Peruta v. San Diego case that decided that the city’s restrictive gun control laws were constitutional. Other than Thomas, Republican-appointed judges slightly outnumber Democrat-appointed judges on the 9th Circuit bench. If we can assume that partisan leanings are indicative of the way that a judge will rule in this case, there is a slight advantage on the gun rights side of the ledger. 

It is important to note that, while the court ruled in Duncan’s favor, the magazine ban remains in effect, at least for now. The National Shooting Sports Federation (NSSF), the firearm industry’s trade association, warned that "While the holding in Duncan is a tremendous victory for the Second Amendment, members of the industry should continue to refrain from selling or shipping into California LCMs until after the appeal proceeding is concluded or the stay is modified or lifted."

While the fight isn’t over, this was a crucially important first step in the fight to roll back unconstitutional restrictions on the Second Amendment. In light of the fact that we could see a Democrat president elected in November, as well as a majority in both houses of Congress, the courts may be our only recourse for defending our rights. The ruling in this case sets up a scenario where that is entirely possible.


GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Guns & Ammo TV: Cameras Don

Guns & Ammo TV: Cameras Don't Lie: 9mm vs .45 ACP

The age-old question, 9mm vs .45 ACP. For some, this has been asked and answered already. For others, the debate goes on. In this segment of “Cameras Don't Lie,” competitive shooters Patrick Sweeney and Jim Tarr head to the range to put the vaunted loads on record, and then consider the footage.

Guns & Ammo TV: Shooting 1,270 Yards with the 5.56 NATO

Guns & Ammo TV: Shooting 1,270 Yards with the 5.56 NATO

Guns & Ammo Rifles & Optics Editor Tom Beckstrand was on location in Idaho where he pushed the limits of the 5.56 NATO cartridge in this segment of “Long Range Tech” for Guns & Ammo TV. Pairing a SIG Sauer MCX Virtus rifle loaded with Hornady's 73-grain ELD-M ammunition, Beckstrand attempted to ring steel set at 1,270 yards, an incredible distance for any 5.56-chambered rifle and beyond the typical range for an AR-15.

Trijicon

Trijicon's New Specialized Reflex Optics (SRO)

The Trijicon SRO is specifically designed for pistol use. The wide field of view and clean, crisp dot makes it easy for users to find and track the dot in both target and competitive shooting applications.

Surefire XSC Micro-Compact Pistol Light: First Look

Surefire XSC Micro-Compact Pistol Light: First Look

Small, lightweight and purpose-built for sub-compact carry guns, Surefire's XSC pistol light takes on EDC illumination segment.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

How-To

9 Commonly Misused Gun Terms

Kyle Wintersteen

"Assault weapon." Sixteen-round "clip." A box of "bullets." When it comes to guns and gun...

The Taurus TX22 rimfire shoots like no other. Reviews

Taurus TX22 Rimfire Review

Eric Poole - May 23, 2019

The Taurus TX22 rimfire shoots like no other.

The Browning X-Bolt Hell's Canyon Speed Long Range McMillan is arguably the best production-grade precision hunting rifle available. Rifles

Review: Browning X-Bolt Hell's Canyon Speed Long Range McMillan

Joseph von Benedikt - March 25, 2019

The Browning X-Bolt Hell's Canyon Speed Long Range McMillan is arguably the best...

In this segment of “At The Range,” Handgunning Editor Jeremy Stafford and contributor Patrick Sweeney compare the visibility of red and green lasers in outdoor, sunny conditions. Accessories

Red vs. Green Lasers: Visibility in Bright Light

Guns & Ammo Staff - August 24, 2020

In this segment of “At The Range,” Handgunning Editor Jeremy Stafford and contributor Patrick...

See More Trending Articles

More 2nd Amendment

Virginia has always been an extremely friendly environment for gun owners since Republicans took control of the Assembly more than 20 years ago, but things have changed. 2nd Amendment

Gun Control in Virginia

Keith Wood - July 17, 2020

Virginia has always been an extremely friendly environment for gun owners since Republicans...

Though the Brady Act lapsed with the creation of the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NCIS) in 1998, many state-­level restrictions remain on the books. But do they work? 2nd Amendment

Do Waiting Periods Prevent Crime?

Keith Wood - March 20, 2020

Though the Brady Act lapsed with the creation of the National Instant Criminal Background...

On Friday, August 14, 2020, the a three-judge panel from the United States Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit released its opinion in Duncan vs. Becerra, a case that challenged the California ban on magazines that hold more than 10 rounds. 2nd Amendment

California Magazine Ban Update

Guns & Ammo Staff - August 18, 2020

On Friday, August 14, 2020, the a three-judge panel from the United States Court of Appeals...

Perspective from the National Shooting Sports Foundation.

NSSF: Sen. Tammy Duckworth's Gun-Control Talking Points in Everytown Veepstakes

National Shooting Sports Foundation - July 28, 2020

Perspective from the National Shooting Sports Foundation.

See More 2nd Amendment

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now