Skip to main content

Stand Your Ground: Feds Leave a Misleading Message

Stand Your Ground: Feds Leave a Misleading Message

President Obama and Attorney General Holder have recently called for an examination of state stand-your-ground laws in reaction to the acquittal of George Zimmerman. Not only is this a vast overreach by federal officials into an area of law that has historically been left to the states, it shows the Obama administration's eagerness to capitalize on any opportunity to pursue its anti-gun, anti-self-defense agenda.

What the president and attorney general fail to realize is that there has already been an examination of self-defense laws in state legislatures and courts across the country. Simply put, the majority have concluded that stand-your-ground is good public policy, because it fully protects Americans' fundamental right to self-defense.

Unsatisfied with the call for examination of stand-your-ground by the president and attorney general, Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee (D-Texas) recently reintroduced H.R. 2812, the "Justice Exists for All of Us Act of 2013." H.R. 2812 would make deep cuts in federal criminal justice grants to any state that does not repeal its stand-your-ground law. Rep. Jackson Lee does not seem to be bothered that H.R. 2812 would be most detrimental to her law-abiding constituents, while giving violent criminals in her district the upper hand. Texas, like the majority of other states, has a stand-your-ground law.

In today's debate about stand-your-ground, a significant amount of misinformation has been circulated concerning the history of the doctrine and what the actual difference is between a state with it and one without it. The claim that stand-your-ground began in Florida in 2005 as a recent departure from "traditional" self-defense rules is false. Stand-your-ground has its roots in the 19th century, when American courts rejected the English retreat requirement in favor of a rule that treated the defender as a citizen with inalienable rights, not as an expendable subject of the crown.


Stand-your-ground, otherwise known as no-duty-to-retreat, does not, as many have claimed, expand the places in which a person can use deadly force in self-defense. It simply allows a person who reasonably believes that an attacker presents a threat of serious injury or death to use deadly force to stop the attack without first trying to run away. Yet even in a state that requires retreat, a person may use deadly force in self-defense anywhere the person is legally present when retreat is not physically possible.


To understand the importance of stand-your-ground, consider a woman who, through no fault of her own, is attacked in a public place, reasonably determines the attacker means to kill her, and responds with her lawfully-carried .38 Special. In a state that requires retreat, she, the victim of the initial attack, could still be convicted for not attempting to retreat. In that instance, the jury, deliberating with the benefit of hindsight after the fact, would simply need to decide that the woman, who was forced to make her split-second decision while facing a violent attack, could have done more to flee the scene.

In an especially revealing example of how little some understand the right to self-defense, Mark Glaze, executive director of Michael Bloomberg's Mayors Against Illegal Guns, argued that firearms should only be used in self-defense against an attacker armed with a firearm. In an appearance on MSNBC's Hardball, Glaze told host Chris Matthews that someone confronted by an attacker wielding an ax handle should "talk" or "fight with their fists." When Matthews asked, "How do you talk to a guy with an ax handle?" Glaze replied, "You fight him. You run away. You deescalate the situation."

Glaze apparently doesn't realize, or care, that some people are physically incapable of running away or fighting with their fists. He also apparently doesn't realize, or care, that requiring innocent victims to fight attackers with their fists or attempting to run away exposes them to increased danger. He clearly can't see past his anti-gun agenda to understand that firearms serve a vital role in protecting those who have no other viable means of fighting back.

States that have enacted stand-your-ground laws give victims of unlawful violence a fighting chance, both at the scene of the attack and in the courtroom. Criminals have less to lose by attempting a violent assault in a duty-to-retreat state, since the law requires victims to submit, or run away, or face possible criminal conviction. In a stand-your-ground state, however, criminals must consider the possibility that victims are willing and able to defend themselves on the spot.




The effect of stand-your-ground laws is to make an already dangerous situation less dangerous for the innocent victim and more dangerous for the criminal. In short, they give law-abiding citizens a critical advantage against predatory criminals. And that's why the NRA will continue to support the passage of stand-your-ground laws in states across the country.

Current Magazine Cover

Enjoy articles like this?

Subscribe to the magazine.

Get access to everything Guns & Ammo has to offer.
Subscribe to the Magazine

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Benelli Lupo Bolt-Action Rifle Review

Benelli Lupo Bolt-Action Rifle Review

It is unlike any other rifle on the market because it offers features no one else does; those looking for a rifle that fits like a custom-made firearm should look no further than the Benelli Lupo.

Cameras Don

Cameras Don't Lie: Subsonic 9mm vs. .300 Blackout

In this segment of "Cameras Don't Lie," a subsonic-ammo showdown, 9mm vs. .300 Blackout fired from AR rifles.

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

At the heart of the rifle is the Model 2020 action which wish designed and built with very tight tolerances thanks to Springfield's technology-driven manufacturing capabilities The stainless steel action features an integral recoil lug, and pairs with a fluted bolt employing dual cocking cams and an enhanced extractor for high pressure loads. The blueprinted and precisely machined action allows Springfield to offer the Model 2020 with .75" MOA accuracy guarantee. Despite being a production rifle, the Model 2020 should rival more expensive custom builds.

Trijicon

Trijicon's New Specialized Reflex Optics (SRO)

The Trijicon SRO is specifically designed for pistol use. The wide field of view and clean, crisp dot makes it easy for users to find and track the dot in both target and competitive shooting applications.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

The United States Army has adopted the SIG Sauer Tango6T 1-6x24mm as its new dedicated optic for squad designated marksmen.SIG Sauer Tango6T 1-6x24mm Review Optics

SIG Sauer Tango6T 1-6x24mm Review

Tom Beckstrand - December 31, 2020

The United States Army has adopted the SIG Sauer Tango6T 1-6x24mm as its new dedicated optic...

You might be surprised how many Americans (even gun owners) think machine guns are illegal.Machine Guns — Can You Own One? Rifles

Machine Guns — Can You Own One?

Eric R. Poole - December 15, 2020

You might be surprised how many Americans (even gun owners) think machine guns are illegal.

Small, lightweight and purpose-built for sub-compact carry guns, Surefire's XSC pistol light takes on EDC illumination segment.Surefire XSC Micro-Compact Pistol Light: First Look Tactical

Surefire XSC Micro-Compact Pistol Light: First Look

Jeremy Stafford - September 10, 2020

Small, lightweight and purpose-built for sub-compact carry guns, Surefire's XSC pistol light...

See More Trending Articles

More Industry

Where has all of the ammo gone?2020 Ammo Shortage Industry

2020 Ammo Shortage

Keith Wood - December 23, 2020

Where has all of the ammo gone?

We all have mentors in life, but for many of us the most influential among them are our dads. As Father's Day approached, I found myself reflecting on my own.Father's Day Thoughts Industry

Father's Day Thoughts

Keith Wood - August 20, 2020

We all have mentors in life, but for many of us the most influential among them are our dads....

Former Guns & Ammo Editor Richard Erik Venola passed away on February 6, 2021, in Nye County, Nevada. He was 62. The shooting world — his world — is much the poorer for it.Richard Venola: September 18, 1958 - February 6, 2021 Industry

Richard Venola: September 18, 1958 - February 6, 2021

Payton Miller and Eric R. Poole - February 16, 2021

Former Guns & Ammo Editor Richard Erik Venola passed away on February 6, 2021, in Nye County,...

The USA High School Clay Target League announced the clay target disciplines of ‘Sporting Clays' and ‘5-Stand' have been added to their high school clay target shooting programs, in which over 30,000 student athletes participate. USA High School Clay Target League Sporting Clays and 5-Stand Programs Industry

USA High School Clay Target League Sporting Clays and 5-Stand Programs

Guns & Ammo Staff - August 01, 2020

The USA High School Clay Target League announced the clay target disciplines of ‘Sporting...

See More Industry

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Guns & Ammo App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now