Skip to main content

SIG P365 XL Review

SIG P365 XL Review
Mike Anschuetz Photo

This year’s summer release of the SIG Sauer P365 XL was the most anticipated launch since the first P365 debuted on the cover of our May 2018 issue. The original P365 was groundbreaking, winning the 2018 Guns & Ammo Handgun of the Year award and knocking off the single-­stack Glock 43, which had only been introduced three years prior to similar fanfare, as America’s best-­selling concealed carry pistol. Just as fast as the G43 made the .380-­chambered G42 a cheap gun store trade-­in, the P365 stunted sales of the G43 once supply caught up with demand.

The P365 instantly secured its place as the gold standard to which all other single-­ and double-­stack 9mms are compared. I say “secured” because its magazine was cleverly designed as a unique stack-­and-­a-­half that’s currently protected by three patents. Engineers at other manufacturers have been frustrated by their inability to work around these patents and stuff just as many rounds of 9mm in a magazine with similar dimensions.

The once-­hot G43 only offered six-­plus-­one capacity magazines, which brought about an aftermarket selling plus-­one and plus-­two extensions. The only option to carry more rounds without a reload was to purchase a double-­stack pistol, but those interested in the G43 wanted it for its slim 1.02-­inch-­wide proportions.

Double-­stack pistols such as the Glock 26 (1.18 inches wide) and newer HK VP9 SK (1.31 inches wide) may be great pistols, but they tend to feel fat in the hand and are more of a challenge to conceal comfortably, which is what gave rise to the single-­stack subcompact market in the first place. Now, let’s consider the new P365 XL.


The Longslide 

Guns & Ammo sources our own independent measurements, so the specifications that follow may or may not agree with the manufacturer’s data. Our P365 XL featured a barrel length of 3.695 inches, measured from the breech block’s hood to the muzzle. The P365 barrel measured 3.091 inches; The XL’s slide was .675-­inch longer than the P365’s. With similar proportions, this extension gives the XL a 5.6-­inch sight radius compared to the P365’s 4.85 inches.


SIG P365 XL
A comparison of the standard P365 (yellow) and the P365 XL. (Mike Anschuetz Photo)

Sight radius matters to some because a longer slide typically allows sharp eyes to define the edges of the front sight within the blurred rear notch for more precise visual discernment. The SIG Sauer X-­Ray3 day/night sights, which are standard on both pistols, are similar, but different at the rear.

SIG P365 XL
SIG Sauer X-Ray3 sights remain a three-dot night sight configuration with a bright green ring at the front. The P365 XL now features a removable rear sight plate that allows mounting of a mini red dot. (Mike Anschuetz Photo)

The P365s we evaluated came with a three-­dot tritium sight system. The notch between the two X-­Ray3 rear sights measured .15-­inch, the same width as the front X-­Ray3 sight. However, the rear sight on the P365 featured horizontal serrations across the back, intended to minimize the reflection of direct sunlight. The new rear sight lacks serrations. The XL’s front sight features the same bright, green ring surrounding a fine, tritium night-­sight vial. I have 20/15 vision and I perceived an improved sight alignment when shooting the XL.

G&A staff chronographed both the P365 and P365 XL with the same SIG Sauer 115-­grain V-­Crown ammunition. There was no difference in the average velocity of 1,110 feet per second (fps). Ballistically, the longer slide of the XL offers no extra benefit, but when testing for accuracy with the X-­Ray3 sights and the same V-­Crown load, the average size of our 25-­yard five-­shot group was reduced to 1.78 inches with the XL compared to the 1.97 average of the standard P365.

SIG P365 XL
(Mike Anschuetz Photo)

Underneath the slide, the striker-­fire assemblies are almost identical. However, there are now two, .625-­inch-­long Torx-­head screws that secure the new X-­Ray3 rear sight from under the slide. (The standard P365 rear sight is dovetailed to the slide.) Remove the slide to remove these screws and install a micro red dot sight. SIG Sauer’s new RomeoZero ($250) is a snap to install and it fits perfectly within the factory sight cut. The slide will also accept a Shield RMSc ($400).


Besides the added length and weight at the muzzle, the slides and barrels are otherwise the same. Different are the guiderod and recoil spring. The recoil spring assembly in the shorter P365 is a compound part, meaning there are two progressive springs with one rod plunging inside an outer rod. This system manages recoil to run the P365’s shorter slide. Because the P365 XL has a longer raceway for the slide to recoil against, it utilizes a single captured spring and guiderod assembly.

The Lower 

Not only is the P365 XL longer, it is also taller, with a grip extending .587 inch. Interestingly, the P365 XL with the flush-­fit 12-­round magazine installed measured the same height as an original P365 with optional 12-­round magazine inserted. The frame is also longer due to a new beavertail that breaks up the flush profile with the bottom of the slide as seen on the standard P365.

The arch of the backstrap and the contour of the triggerguard’s untextured undercut appear the same, but there’s more purchase area at the frontstrap due to the longer grip. At the range, this resulted in felt recoil that was more manageable than the P365’s, which wasn’t bad either.


Combining the extra weight out at the front of the slide with the longer grip and beavertail made shooting the P365 XL impressively controllable, regardless of a 9mm’s bullet weight and velocity. In total, the XL weighed 1 pound, 4.7 ounces compared to the P365’s weight of 1 pound, 1.8 ounces. The P365 XL is easier to shoot, in part, because there is almost 3 ounces of weight at the muzzle.

Texturing surrounds both grip modules and will wear down with use. It’s a rough texture, but not something that can be classified as aggressive; It’s a nice balance that also improves control of the gun.

SIG P365 XL
The grip on the P365 XL wears the same rough texture as the original, but it is lon-ger and flared slightly at the magwell. (Mike Anschuetz Photo)

At the base of the grip, the standard P365 features a pair of notches at the side, which fit like a puzzle piece with the magazine’s baseplate as well as the optional angled baseplate and 12-­round extension. The XL’s funneled magazine well does not.

The P365’s 10 and extended 12-­round magazines, and the P365 XL’s standard 12 and optional 15-round magazines blur the lines between a single-­stack 9mm pistol and and a larger double-­stack subcompact. The FN FNS-­9C, Ruger SR9c, Springfield Armory XD-­9 Mod.2 subcompact, Taurus G2C and Walther PPQ SC all offer magazines that match or offer greater capacity, but none are as slim as the P365 or P365 XL. The P365 measured 4.74 inches tall with the longer 12-­round magazine, and the P365 XL measured 5.35 inches with the optional 15-­round mag inserted. For their capacity, the P365 and P365 XL have no competition in size and profile.

Trigger Time 

A visual difference between the P365 and the P365 XL is the trigger; The P365 features a curved trigger while the P365 XL has a flat trigger. For being flat, the XL trigger actually has a longer length of pull from center at 2.7 inches. The curved trigger on the standard P365 measured 2.61 inches. I’ll leave it up to you whether flat or curved triggers are better, but larger hands might prefer the new flat trigger for the increased length of pull. This was a clever way for SIG Sauer to address any complaints about a short length of pull from large-­handed shooters without changing the dimensions of the trigger’s location on the frame.

SIG P365 XL
Keeping with trends, the P365 XL features a flat trigger, which actually increases the reach. This feel of this trigger could be improved with a shorter, smoother takeup and less overtravel. (Mike Anschuetz Photo)

To me, what’s more important is how a trigger feels. I personally own two box-­stock P365s, one with more than 3,000 rounds through it. Both trigger pulls feel similar and average 6 pounds, 6 ounces on a Lyman digital trigger-pull gauge. The trigger pulls on the P365 XL measured almost a pound lighter at 5½ pounds. However, there’s just something about the XL’s trigger that makes it feel longer and interrupted as it is pressed.

Load Up!

The P365 XL features a flared magazine well that’s funneled to gobble up either of the two supplied standard 12-round magazine or an optional 15-round magazine. The 12-round mag fits flush and will function in a standard P365 — and so will the 15-round magazine! Once they appeared on SIG Sauer’s webstore for $49, they became their own commodity.

SIG P365 XL
The magazine well is slightly flared and funneled. The base-pad is also different as the P365 XL lacks the top tab. However, XL mags will work in the P365. (Mike Anschuetz Photo)

The basepads on any of the P365 magazines can be changed to fill the void and improve the grip, but there’s no contour at the bottom of the 15-rounder. The square corner of the box pokes at the heel of the shooting hand, which I found uncomfortable. This is odd, in my opinion, because the 12-round magazines feature an arched, textured tail that blends well with the backstrap. This suggests that engineers could have designed a more comfortable baseplate for the 15-round mag. Regardless, it’s hard to argue given the 15-plus-one capacity is now available for either pistol.

SIG P365 XL
(Mike Anschuetz Photo)

Like the original, the P365 XL points well for me. It requires little effort to align the sights instantly or learn how to use a red dot. At the range, the P365 XL proved to be a very accurate pistol. With iron sights, results averaged between 1.7 inches for the best five-shot groups fired from a bench at 25 yards to 2.2 inches. It was noteworthy that there were not the usual flyers that we experience when testing other pistols. Every round fired from the P365 XL seemed to hit its mark.

Once SIG Sauer’s new RomeoZero red dot was installed and sighted in, the groups shrunk even more. In fact, during function testing with Federal’s 147-grain Hydra Shock load, I fired five shots while standing offhand (and unsupported) into a group that measured 1.44 inches! Even more incredible was that all five shots were centered inside the 10 ring. Like a proud kid, I saved the target to hang up when I got home.

I used to struggle with an answer when someone would come up and ask if a particular handgun was a good choice for personal defense. “It depends,” I’d say. These days, I usually reply with another question: “Have you looked at a SIG Sauer P365?”

The P365 XL is no better or worse of a pistol than the standard model. Whether it’s right for you will largely depend on handsize and your ability to conceal the grip without printing. I’m sure of one thing: One of them is probably going to suit you well.

SIG P365 XL
Notes: Accuracy is the average of five, five-shot groups fired from 25 yards. Velocity is the average of five shots measured by an Oehler Model 35P chronograph.

SIG Sauer P365 XL

  • Type: Striker fired, recoil operated, semiautomatic
  • Cartridge: 9mm
  • Capacity: 12+1 rds. (2 incl.); 15+1 rds. (optional)
  • Barrel: 3.7 in.; carbon steel
  • Overall Length: 6.6 in.
  • Height: 4.8 in.
  • Width: 1.1 in.
  • Weight: 1 lb., 4.7 oz.
  • Grip Module: XL; textured polymer
  • Finish: Nitron (stainless steel)
  • Trigger: 4 lbs., 8 oz.; flat
  • Sights: SIG X-Ray3; optic ready
  • MSRP: $685
  • Manufacturer: SIG Sauer, 603-610-3000, sigsauer.com 
Current Magazine Cover

Enjoy articles like this?

Subscribe to the magazine.

Get access to everything Guns & Ammo has to offer.
Subscribe to the Magazine

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Trijicon

Trijicon's New Specialized Reflex Optics (SRO)

The Trijicon SRO is specifically designed for pistol use. The wide field of view and clean, crisp dot makes it easy for users to find and track the dot in both target and competitive shooting applications.

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout cartridge was developed to provide greater effectiveness than a 9mm at short and medium ranges when fired from a short-barreled suppressed firearm. Just because the cartridge wasn't designed to go long doesn't mean Rifles & Optics Editor Tom Beckstrand won't take it there, using a large-format pistol, no less. Armed with SIG Sauer's 9-inch-barreled MCX Virtus Pistol loaded with Black Hills' 125-grain TMK ammunition, Beckstrand attempts to ring steel at 600 yards with help from Hornady's 4DOF ballistic calculator in this segment of “Long Range Tech.”

Trijicon RMRcc Reflex Sight – Perfect for Optics-Ready Concealed-Carry Pistols

Trijicon RMRcc Reflex Sight – Perfect for Optics-Ready Concealed-Carry Pistols

The people asked and Trijicon answered. Introducing the RMRcc miniature red-dot sight for compact, concealed-carry pistols. Trijicon's new RMRcc features the durability and reliable controls that have made the RMR so successful, but its reduced dimensions make the “Concealed Carry” model better suited for the popular small-frame pistols designed for discreet carry and personal defense.

Red vs. Green Lasers: Visibility in Bright Light

Red vs. Green Lasers: Visibility in Bright Light

In this segment of “At The Range,” Handgunning Editor Jeremy Stafford and contributor Patrick Sweeney compare the visibility of red and green lasers in outdoor, sunny conditions.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

In this segment of Air Gun Reviews: Ruger 10/22 Air Rifle Rifles

Air Gun Reviews: Ruger 10/22 Air Rifle

Guns & Ammo Staff - September 02, 2020

In this segment of "Guns & Ammo TV," Gun Tech Editor Richard Nance and Pro-Shooter Jim Tarr...

The Taurus TX22 rimfire shoots like no other.Taurus TX22 Rimfire Review Reviews

Taurus TX22 Rimfire Review

Eric Poole - May 23, 2019

The Taurus TX22 rimfire shoots like no other.

Don't mortgage the homestead to get into PRS, this is what's available from the likes of Mossberg, Tikka, Savage, Howa, Bergara, Weatherby and Remington.Starter Rifles for Under $1000 Rifles

Starter Rifles for Under $1000

Aaron Carter - May 09, 2019

Don't mortgage the homestead to get into PRS, this is what's available from the likes of...

Some guns are easier to work with than others, but the Ruger American Rifle doesn't require an engineering degree to tinker with; here's a look at some upgrade options to take your Ruger American to the next level, and make it something a bit different.Top Ruger American Rifle Upgrades Accessories

Top Ruger American Rifle Upgrades

Philip Massaro - March 15, 2018

Some guns are easier to work with than others, but the Ruger American Rifle doesn't require an...

See More Trending Articles

More Reviews

Excellent fit and finish are essential for an accurate firearm. While the Wilson Combat Ranger in .350 Legend wasn't made as a precision competitor, it sure performed like one.Wilson Combat Ranger .350 Legend Review Reviews

Wilson Combat Ranger .350 Legend Review

Jim Angell - October 02, 2020

Excellent fit and finish are essential for an accurate firearm. While the Wilson Combat Ranger...

Building on the Ruger American's success­ful foundation, Ruger, Davidson's and Magpul have teamed up to create an exclusive version of the Ruger American Rifle Hunter that is tailored to the long-range shooter.Davidson's Exclusive Ruger American Hunter Review Reviews

Davidson's Exclusive Ruger American Hunter Review

Cody Eardley - September 16, 2020

Building on the Ruger American's success­ful foundation, Ruger, Davidson's and Magpul have...

Rise Armament's meticulousness turns out some mighty fine rifles, including the 1121XR precision rifle.Rise Armament 1121XR Precision Rifle Review Reviews

Rise Armament 1121XR Precision Rifle Review

Tom Beckstrand - October 12, 2020

Rise Armament's meticulousness turns out some mighty fine rifles, including the 1121XR...

The Savage Arms 110 Elite Precision is an excellent all-around rifle for most shooting activities that don't require light weight. It can be made to fit just about anyone, with a chassis that allows for accurate, rapid and effective positional shooting. And while the 110 Elite Precision is not inexpensive, it still costs less than most custom rifles. Savage Arms 110 Elite Precision Review: Excellent All-Around Rifle Reviews

Savage Arms 110 Elite Precision Review: Excellent All-Around Rifle

Proofhouse - September 15, 2020

The Savage Arms 110 Elite Precision is an excellent all-around rifle for most shooting...

See More Reviews

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Guns & Ammo App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now