Skip to main content

Are 1911 Rail Guns Better than the Original?

Are 1911 Rail Guns Better than the Original?

Perhaps the most polarized debate among 1911 aficionados is whether the integral Picatinny rail is welcome on John Browning's classic design.

Purists believe rails defeat the authentic appearance, while others argue they're the gateway for 1911s into the realm of modern firearms.

Those who oppose the presence of rails on Old Slabsides make their case on the grounds of added weight, bulky shape and lack of compatibility with traditional 1911 holsters. Among those in opposition are often the true 1911 connoisseurs who prefer the heritage of a no-frills G.I. model over modern designs with fancy features.

On the other side are those who attach accessories for a more tactical setup. Rail-mounted lights and lasers have become a force multiplier for many operators — especially in military, law enforcement and home-defense applications. Another common segment of the pro-rail crowd are folks who claim they'd rather have rails and not need them than need rails and not have them.


The significance of rails on a 1911 begs the question; If you could only have one 1911, would it have rails or not?


According to 1911 expert Dick Metcalf, "That's like asking Phil Mickelson what club he prefers. It depends on the shot he needs to make." Metcalf went on to say, "If I could only have one 1911, it'd have a rail because of the enhanced versatility. But the Classic 1911 still feels and balances better in my hand."

Thus, the presence of a rail really comes down to the intended application for each individual 1911 operator — whether it be for duty, everyday carry, personal defense or part of a collection.

Those on both sides of the argument often speculate whether John Browning would have included rails on his original design, had the light and laser technology of today been available in the early 20th century. If he could have fastened a tactical candle to the 1911 with the 500-lumen power of a Surefire X300 Ultra, John Browning would have done it.

Based on the sophistication of Browning's firearms, I strongly believe he would have included rails on his original design — especially had he known their benefit to the modern American soldier. As the Picatinny-railed Colt M45A1 CQBP joins the U.S. Marine Corps on the 21st century battlefield, it appears 1911 rail guns have one-up on the original design.


Rock Island Armory Tactical VZ Grip

The Rock Island Armory Tactical VZ Grip is a baseline 1911 that comes out of the box with some great options for the price. Complete with a TruGlo front sight, ambidextrous safety and VZ Grips, this is a practical choice that won't break the bank. This pistol could serve as a reasonable starting point for someone to learn the 1911 platform without going overboard.

Price: $599

ATI Thunderbolt Enhanced

ATI brings its Thunderbolt Enhanced model to market at under [imo-slideshow gallery= 332],000. In addition to a picatinny rail, this 1911 comes with an adjustable target trigger, ambidextrous safety and ported barrel. An adjustable rear sight mounted to the dual-serrated 4140 steel slide makes this a good option for target shooting and plinking.

Price: $899

SIG Sauer Nitron Rail

Folks looking for a few more options in a hand-fitted 1911 should check out the SIG Sauer Nitron Rail. This pistol sports premium internal parts such as a match grade barrel and trigger. Novak night sights ride atop a patented Nitron-finished slide, allowing shooters to stay on target in low-light conditions. This 1911 stands apart from others with its wood grips, as well as checkering on the front strap and mainspring housing. SIG Sauer is known for producing quality guns for law enforcement applications, and this pistol is no exception.

Price: [imo-slideshow gallery= 332],142

Smith & Wesson E-Series 1911TA

Smith & Wesson's tradition of crafting high-quality, American-made guns continues with its E-Series SW1911TA. A unique chainmail pattern serrates each side of the stainless steel slide, while flat-top serrations separate the front and rear tritium night sights. Checkering on the front and back straps are on point with that of premium-quality 1911s. Another value-added feature is Smith & Wesson's lifetime service policy, which will keep your gun running long after you've put it through its paces.

Price: [imo-slideshow gallery= 332],319

Kimber Warrior

Built specifically for tactical operations and combat, the Kimber Warrior comes with some unique features not found on most Kimber 1911s. For instance, the low-profile tactical wedge night sights, ambidextrous safety and KimPro frame finish give this pistol an advantage for practical applications. This service gun also has frame checkering, G10 grips and a built-in lanyard loop to ensure weapon retention. Look to the Warrior as an all-purpose weapon that's a step up from its TLE/RL II cousin.

Price: [imo-slideshow gallery= 332],512

Dan Wesson Specialist

Oftentimes overshadowed by big name brands, Dan Wesson makes some of the highest quality, hand-fitted 1911s for the price. Their small shop in upstate New York gives each gun a personal attention to detail that's normally found only among more high-end manufacturers. The Dan Wesson Specialist has premium forged steel parts, and a matte black duty finish that can really take a beating before showing any wear. It also features a unique set of vertical two-dot, dual-colored tritium night sights for fast sight acquisition in all lighting conditions.

Price: [imo-slideshow gallery= 332],870

Colt Marine Pistol

The only difference between the new military-issued Colt M45A1 and the civilian model — known as the Colt Marine Pistol — is the serial numbers and U.S. Property roll marks. The design of this close quarters battle pistol was adopted by the USMC in July 2012 and will be issued to the most elite Marines in service.

The Colt Marine Pistol is finished in the Colt Custom Shop with a Desert Tan Cerakoted slide and frame, Novak night sights and a lanyard loop attached to the serrated mainspring housing. Internal parts and the match-fit barrel are hand fitted, and each firearm is test fired for optimum quality control. The Marine Pistol comes with the actual target used during testing.

Price: [imo-slideshow gallery= 332],999

Les Baer Ultimate Recon

Its rounded corners and hand fitting make the Les Baer Ultimate Recon an excellent option for a tactical carry gun. The quality many have come to expect from Les Baer is paired with a number of standard features, including a Streamlight TLR-1 attached to the integral picatinny rail. Its fine details include a beveled magazine well, checkered slide stop and flared ejection port.

Price: gallery= 332,370

Wilson Combat CQB Tactical LE

For over 30 years, the name Wilson Combat has been synonymous with the highest quality 1911s on the market. The company's experienced master pistolsmiths hand-tune each CQB Tactical LE to the highest tolerances for advanced SWAT and military special operation applications.

This pistol achieves optimum accuracy with a crisp 3 ½-pound trigger pull, match grade bull barrel and fiber optic front sight. The magazine well is beveled for no-look reloading, and the front strap is checkered with an elegant 30-lines per inch pattern. As with all Wilson Combat products, the CQB Tactical LE can be heavily customized to fit your specific needs.

Price: $3,115

Springfield TRP Light Rail

The Springfield Armory TRP Light Rail comes packed with desirable features for the price. Originally designed around the same specifications as Springfield's FBI-contract 1911, the TRP offers similar performance for the civilian market.

Price: [imo-slideshow gallery= 332],867

Nighthawk AAC Recon

The Nighthawk AAC Recon is a beautiful 1911, and its also a real workhorse. Built in collaboration with Advanced Armament Corporation, the custom serrations on the top of the slide, front strap and mainspring housing lighten the gun while also matching the markings on the AAC Ti-Rant Suppressor.

Other battle-ready features include customized Heinie  Ledge sights, which are designed to give a clear sight picture above the suppressor. Their distinct 'ledge ' shape can be used to cock the weapon on a hard surface as needed. Every component of this gun are expertly fitted and de-horned to create a truly functional work of art.

Price: $3,395 (not including suppressor)

Current Magazine Cover

Enjoy articles like this?

Subscribe to the magazine.

Get access to everything Guns & Ammo has to offer.
Subscribe to the Magazine

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout cartridge was developed to provide greater effectiveness than a 9mm at short and medium ranges when fired from a short-barreled suppressed firearm. Just because the cartridge wasn't designed to go long doesn't mean Rifles & Optics Editor Tom Beckstrand won't take it there, using a large-format pistol, no less. Armed with SIG Sauer's 9-inch-barreled MCX Virtus Pistol loaded with Black Hills' 125-grain TMK ammunition, Beckstrand attempts to ring steel at 600 yards with help from Hornady's 4DOF ballistic calculator in this segment of “Long Range Tech.”

Air Gun Reviews: Why Shoot Airsoft?

Air Gun Reviews: Why Shoot Airsoft?

In this Guns & Ammo TV segment, Gun Tech Editor Richard Nance and Pro-Shooter Jim Tarr discuss the benefits of airsoft training for uniformed professionals and armed citizens alike.

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

At the heart of the rifle is the Model 2020 action which wish designed and built with very tight tolerances thanks to Springfield's technology-driven manufacturing capabilities The stainless steel action features an integral recoil lug, and pairs with a fluted bolt employing dual cocking cams and an enhanced extractor for high pressure loads. The blueprinted and precisely machined action allows Springfield to offer the Model 2020 with .75" MOA accuracy guarantee. Despite being a production rifle, the Model 2020 should rival more expensive custom builds.

Umarex Air Ruger 10/22 Rifle Review

Umarex Air Ruger 10/22 Rifle Review

In this segment of "Guns & Ammo TV," Gun Tech Editor Richard Nance and Pro-Shooter Jim Tarr head to the range to wring out the Umarex Air Ruger 10/22.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

The first in this new family of Springfield Armory rifles is the Model 2020 Waypoint, the result of years of engineering, testing and evaluation, combined with premium grade components found on rifles costing thousands of dollars more.First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle Rifles

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

Guns & Ammo Staff - September 29, 2020

The first in this new family of Springfield Armory rifles is the Model 2020 Waypoint, the...

The Browning X-Bolt Hell's Canyon Speed Long Range McMillan is arguably the best production-grade precision hunting rifle available.Browning X-Bolt Hell's Canyon Speed Long Range McMillan Review Rifles

Browning X-Bolt Hell's Canyon Speed Long Range McMillan Review

Joseph von Benedikt - March 25, 2019

The Browning X-Bolt Hell's Canyon Speed Long Range McMillan is arguably the best...

The Taurus TX22 rimfire shoots like no other.Taurus TX22 Rimfire Review Reviews

Taurus TX22 Rimfire Review

Eric Poole - May 23, 2019

The Taurus TX22 rimfire shoots like no other.

Don't mortgage the homestead to get into PRS, this is what's available from the likes of Mossberg, Tikka, Savage, Howa, Bergara, Weatherby and Remington.Starter Rifles for Under $1000 Rifles

Starter Rifles for Under $1000

Aaron Carter - May 09, 2019

Don't mortgage the homestead to get into PRS, this is what's available from the likes of...

See More Trending Articles

More Tactical

The Streamlight TLR-7 A, a rail-mounted light (primarily for handguns) comes with a high switch on the light and includes a low switch that makes it more comfortable on different size handguns or for users with longer/shorter finger reach to activate. The lightweight and compact new light delivers 500 lumens for a variety of tactical uses.Streamlight TLR-7 A Rail-Mounted Light - First Look Industry

Streamlight TLR-7 A Rail-Mounted Light - First Look

Guns & Ammo Digital Staff - November 15, 2019

The Streamlight TLR-7 A, a rail-mounted light (primarily for handguns) comes with a high...

If you carry for a living or as an armed citizen, the 5.11 Tactical Defender Flex series warrants a hard look. 5.11 Tactical Defender Flex Pants Tactical

5.11 Tactical Defender Flex Pants

Jeremy Stafford - June 28, 2018

If you carry for a living or as an armed citizen, the 5.11 Tactical Defender Flex series...

A Review of Dave Spaulding’s Vehicle Combatives Course.Vehicular Gunfight Tactical

Vehicular Gunfight

Richard Nance - October 06, 2017

A Review of Dave Spaulding’s Vehicle Combatives Course.

With each and every realistic scenario, we  build mind-muscle memory that we  will draw on during a confrontation.Firearms Training And Performance Under Pressure Tactical

Firearms Training And Performance Under Pressure

Kyle Lamb - August 10, 2017

With each and every realistic scenario, we build mind-muscle memory that we will draw on...

See More Tactical

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Guns & Ammo App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now