Guns & Ammo Network

Collapse bottom bar
Gun Culture

G&A Basics: How and When to Sell Guns Online

by James Tarr   |  April 24th, 2013 14


As a gun writer, I like to consider myself a little more well-informed than the average gun owner about most things that go “bang.” Buying and selling guns, ammo and accessories online is no big deal, right? Well, thinking you’re smart and well-informed, and being smart and well-informed are two different things. As of right now, my PayPal account is restricted until I fill out their, “I’m sorry I broke your rules,” document, admitting I violated their Acceptable Use Policy. What did I do?

I had the temerity, the audacity, the cojones to sell an AR-15 magazine on GunBroker, and accept payment through PayPal. When Paypal found out, they restricted my account so that I can now deposit money into it—but not withdraw any—until I fill out and send in their Acceptable Use Policy affidavit.

EBay is well known to be hostile to gun owners, treating firearms, parts and ammunition like the plague, but I thought I was safe working through GunBroker, which specializes in hosting auctions of exactly those kind of products readers of Guns & Ammo would be interested in. Lesson learned. I guess that’s why sellers on GunBroker don’t have PayPal listed as a payment option, but instead take money orders, checks, credit cards, etc.

GunsAmerica has recently instituted a policy that states everything bought on their site has to be paid for with USPS Postal Service Money Orders. As GunsAmerica explains, “If you use USPS money orders and mail them USPS, you generate what they call a ‘nexus’ and if, God forbid, you are scammed online, they will respond to your complaint.”

The USPS has Postal Service Inspectors, and they take fraud seriously.

“Credit cards are the safest way to pay for internet purchases, but only gun dealers are allowed to have a merchant account that can take payments for guns online.” If somebody trying to sell you something online is saying something different, they’re either wrong or somehow trying to scam you.

In doing research for this article, I also found this on GunsAmerica: “Paypal is not an option. Please do not attempt to use it to pay for or to get paid for GunsAmerica sales. Paypal is violently anti-gun and has suspended and frozen thousands of legitimate gun seller accounts over the years.” Too bad I didn’t know that earlier, but hopefully my pain can be your gain.

GunBroker and GunsAmerica are the two of largest Internet auction sites devoted to firearms and accessories, but not the only ones. There are also, and, just to name a few. If you’ve never used one of the online auction sites to buy or sell guns, ammo, or accessories, there are a few things I’ve learned over the years that will help you out.

To buy or sell anything through an online auction site, you’ll have to set up an online user account. Sellers on these websites live and die by their reputation, which is referred to by various terms such as their “feedback” or “user level.” GunBroker uses a grading system that should be familiar to anyone who went to school, A+ being the best. How many total votes they’ve received is also listed, so a seller who has a high grade with a huge number of sales is always the best bet. Sellers to look for on GunsAmerica have a user level that says they are “Trusted” or “Gold.”

Online auction sites are so popular and useful, they are used by gun stores and professional sellers as much or more now than they are by private citizens. This isn’t a bad thing. Selling stuff online requires very little investment and reaches a wide audience, so gun stores and FFL holders can often sell guns more cheaply online than stores who only do face-to-face business.

When you have something to sell and have an account set up, most of the auction sites have easy-to-use walkthroughs to show you how to set up your own auction. The fees they charge for putting up a listing can range from a few bucks to a few dozen, and the fees are usually only charged after the item has sold. Most of the time the fees are calculated as a percentage of the selling price—1 to 2 percent on GunsAmerica based on your membership level, and 1.25 to 5 percent on GunBroker based on the price of the item sold.

One helpful hint: Always upload a photo of what you’re selling. If you don’t, not only will most potential buyers pass up your listing, anyone still interested will just email you asking for a photo.

GunBroker and its like aren’t the only useful places to track down good deals online. Whatever type of firearm you fancy, chances are there is a forum devoted to it somewhere—such as, where collectors gather.

Perhaps the largest firearms forum is “Arfcom,” as it is known, is a huge site that isn’t just devoted to ARs, and gun companies know this. Manufacturers have a large presence on the site, not just through ads but through forum posts talking about new products, or talking their customers through problems they may be experiencing. Many companies frequently have special deals available only to members of Arfcom. Arfcom also has their Equipment Exchange, where members who want to buy, sell, trade or get involved in group buys send emails back and forth.

When dealing with individual sellers, the potential for being scammed is always higher. There’s no way to completely eliminate fraud, so just use common sense—if a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. Also, if the seller only provides stock photos, wants you to mail your payment to a P.O. Box or maybe a different state even though they’re selling one of their “personal” items, or does anything else that raises your red flags, you have only yourself to blame if you send your payment and never see anything in return.

When is the best time to buy and/or sell? Well, if you’ve got any sort of semi-auto, magazine-fed rifle you’re looking to part with, now would be the time. The same goes for any ammunition or AR or AK magazines—they are all drawing premium prices. Legally, buyers are responsible for making sure the products they’re purchasing are legal in their city/state, but as a seller, you should learn which states have banned certain items. That is why so many gun companies have stopped sales of ARs and standard capacity magazines to departments and even individual law enforcement officers in ban zones such as New York, because they don’t want to run afoul of new and ever-changing gun laws.

When you post your listing, you want as many people as possible to have the chance to look at it, so don’t have it run over a holiday weekend. Again, use common sense—Hawaiian shirts sell better in June than they do in January. If you live in a place which sees snow on the ground six months of the year and only want to sell your competition rifle to a local, February is not a good time to put it up for sale.

  • T.D. Honeycutt

    Why not deal with the media fiction that anyone can buy a gun on the Internet? I’ve purchased numerous guns via AuctionArms, and have completed a 4473 each time certifying that I’m not restricted from owning a firearm. Yet the media gushes about how people go out and buy guns on the Internet. Also, a good topic is abiding by ATF rules. I live in a border state, and when I use sites like, I’m frequently contacted by residents of other states who want to buy my firearm. No problem, they say. I have a CHL. Well, read the ATF FAQ and you’ll learn that no individual can buy from or sell to another individual unless each are residents of the same state.

  • John

    Pretty much the same as my experience. I would like to add an additional item to consider because it cost me a gun. At my location the best bet for shipping is UPS. They are timely and reasonable. Use FedEx only if it is the single option for delivery and you simply must have the gun. FedEx stole my gun under the pretext of examining it. I made it available at my FFL for examination. Rather than examine it, the driver picked it up leaving a pickup number. Since that time FedEx has refused to return the gun and denies any knowledge of its location despite being given the pickup number the driver left. And it was not a cheap gun: a benchrest rifle built on a Mauser blue-printed action with a bull barrel and stocked by Fajen with a beautiful tiger-stripe walnut figure in the wood. Details available to anyone seriously challenging this charge.

  • Tim

    I wish some outfit would come out with a pay system similar to PayPal that was pro gun. I know there used to be GunPal but I think it is gone.

  • doliver

    PH^CK EBAY & PAYPAL Never will I do business through them much to the consternation of some who do.

  • Bowserb

    I haven’t used paypal since 2004, but I just logged on and formally closed my account.


    I run “” which is a penny auction site. Not only was i operating for 3 months before Paypal informed me I was illegal, then froze my payment options, they kept the account closed until all things Paypal where removed from my coding. This cost thousands in new code for my website and store. But Paypal isnt the only one that is anti-gun, you literally have to figure out tricks to by-pass the regs on Google, Yahoo, and Facebook to advertise. I was banned from advertising on Facebook and when I asked “why or how to be compliant” the response was “our ruling is final”.

  • Ray

    This gun writer is an idiot. He knows eBay is hostile but thought PayPal was OK??? PayPal is owned by eBay. He states GunBroker Sellers don’t offer PayPal as a payment option, but way too many of them do offer PayPal as an option. I don’t purchase from GB Sellers or any other business that offers (read SUPPORTS) PayPal as a payment option. When I see a GB Seller that offers ‘discrete PayPal’ as a payment option, I report them to PayPal. It prevents the support of PayPal and gets the losers account frozen: win win. To add to the insanity, the not gun writer implies that he is going to fill out the “broke your rules” document so he can continue with his SUPPORT of PayPal!! What a shame. As long as stupid people continue to support eBay and PayPal and all of the other anti gun groups, we deserve whatever happens to our 2nd Amendment Rights.

    • Frank

      I sell on both Gunbroker and ebay. I have had several lengthy emails with Paypal regarding the rules on guns etc. You can accept PayPal for: magazines less than 11 rounds, bullets, casings, rails, stocks, optics, barrels, etc etc. you CANNOT accept PayPal for this short list: firearms, hi capacity magazines, live ammo. I don’t consider them anti-gun, just prudent on thei watch for liability.

      • Hamilton

        Liability? You really think they’re worried about liability if either buyer or seller, or both, violate any sort of rules? Oh brother.

  • BigShooter

    Ironically, with recent revelations about the security issues at PayPal, you’re better off that you can’t use them. And don’t confuse bad service with politics…either liberal or conservative. PayPal isn’t so much anti-gun as much as they’re anti-customer.

  • John Dalton

    Just an FYI, Paypal will happily do all transactions as long as they are listed as “Metal sculpture” purchases. I have sold a number of “Metal Sculptures” without issue.

  • Larry Lipman

    My company is about to release a pin debit program on line. It has a scrambler so it can not be hacked. The system reduces fraud, chargebacks and fees. Who would like to know more about this?

  • joe

    pulling my hair out…..have a gun built buy..or..for H. jones…in Tidioute PA.1840’s to 1850’s. cant find any more info on it….over under…..any idea’s…could use the help..ty

back to top