Skip to main content

Maine Bear Hunting in the Hands of Voters

bear-1The future of Maine bear hunting lays in the hands of state voters. A ballot initiative known as Question 1 would ban the use of traps, bait and hounds, leaving still-hunting as the only legal method. The measure is on the state ballot Nov. 4, 2014. The referendum is funded almost entirely by the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS), the country's largest and most powerful anti-hunting organization. 

If Question 1 passes, it would not only take away the state wildlife agency's most effective black bear management tools, it would cripple Maine's outfitter industry. Bear guides rely on baiting and hounds, says Sportsman's Alliance of Maine executive director David Trahan.

"Many, many outfitters will go out of business. That's the untold story here. These are hard-working men and women who have been outfitters all their lives. It's all they know," he says. "It's not like they would be able to get another job. Most of these outfitters live in rural communities with a very limited job market, so they would likely go bankrupt."

Trahan says studies have shown that bear hunting contributes $60 million to the state economy and accounts for upward of 800 jobs.


The loss of bait and hounds as hunting methods won't just devastate small towns and the outfitters who support them. It would cripple the state's ability to effectively manage bears. Baiting, trapping and hounds together account for 93 percent of the annual statewide harvest of about 3,000 bears.


RELATED: What's the Best Bear Hunting Method?

A ban on those methods would result in an upswing in the state's bear population, which stands at 30,000 animals, and bear/human conflicts will surely increase as they have in other states with growing black bear populations. Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife (DIFW) biologist Gerry Levigne cited examples of the effect of bait and hound bans in other states in a report he wrote for the Sportsman's Alliance of Maine. Hundreds of nuisance bears are now killed by state wildlife agencies instead of by sport hunters. Oregon officials kill 400 each year, and about 600 were killed in Colorado in 2012. One Colorado county went so far as to ban the use of levered door handles because bears have become adept at entering homes fitted with those types of handles. Massachusetts' bear population increased by 700 percent since the bait ban went into effect in 1970. Hunting with hounds was outlawed in 1996. Complaints have more than doubled in Massachusetts as bears encroach on the state's suburban regions.

"If we lose these methods, DIFW loses the ability to control the size and health of Maine's black bear population," wrote Levigne. "A growing bear population that routinely exceeds its wild food supply is a recipe for escalating bear/human conflicts."

RELATED: Coyote Attacks Chicago Boy in City Park


Bears can self-regulate their populations, but what anti-hunting groups don't seem to grasp is that "natural" population control typically involves methods more cruel than any type of hunting. Adult males kill cubs more frequently when populations are at or over carrying capacity, and young males will fight over territory as more bears are squeezed into the landscape, often inflicting fatal wounds on each other.

"As a population grows," wrote Levigne in his report, "competition becomes fierce for the high-quality foods," which results in malnutrition, particularly for younger and smaller animals.

Contrary to claims by Question 1 proponents, the three methods under attack are in no way giving hunters an unfair advantage. The state's 12,000 bear hunters have a 25 percent success rate and spend an average of 15 days afield before they kill a bear. Trappers have an even lower success rate, and success rates for still-hunters are the lowest of all methods.


This isn't the first time the HSUS has attempted to subvert professional wildlife management in Maine. A similar ballot initiative was defeated in 2004 by just a four-point margin. Anti-hunters gathered about 97,000 signatures, far more than the required number to place the referendum before Maine's voters.

Despite that narrow loss, the anti-hunting group has claimed a number of victories related to bear management. Colorado, for example, banned baiting, hounds and a spring hunting season in 1992. The referendum passed by a landslide 70-to-30 margin. Voters in Oregon and Washington also passed ballot initiatives that restricted bear hunting methods, but Michigan, Idaho and Alaska voters rejected similar referendums between 1996 and 2004.

Win or lose, it's all part of the organization's ultimate goal to end all hunting.

HSUS Executive Director Wayne Pacelle said in a 1991 interview with the Associated Press, "If we could shut down all sport hunting in a moment, we would." That may seem like a far-fetched goal, but between 1990 and 2012, the animal rights group backed 45 state ballot measures that related to everything from farming and dog racing to trapping and wolf hunting. They were victorious on 30, including a ban on mountain lion hunting in California, trapping in Arizona and a continued ban on dove hunting in Ohio.

Trahan thinks Maine voters understand what's at stake. A poll conducted in September found that two-thirds of state voters who understood the issue would reject Question 1. To boost the public education campaign, the Sportsman's Alliance of Maine raised $2 million dollars, much of it spent on television, radio and newspaper advertising. Equally important, the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife has been active in its opposition to Question 1.

"Our state wildlife biologists and wardens have been out front on this issue and what it would mean to the state if it did pass," says Trahan.

Surprisingly, though, the referendum also has wide-ranging support from a variety of in-state businesses, wildlife experts and community leaders. To view a full list, visit fairbearhunt.com.

While Trahan and other bear-hunting supporters are concerned about the outcome, they that agree public sentiment seems to be on their side. That's due in part to a fatal bear attack in New Jersey in September. A Rutgers University student was killed by a black bear while hiking in the Apshawa Preserve with four friends.

"I think that was a game-changer," says Trahan. "It brought a bit of reality to the issue. If we can't successfully manage our bears through the current methods, we could see this sort of thing happen in Maine. No one wants that."

G&A WANTS TO KNOW: Where do you stand on this issue? Vote and join the debate below.

Current Magazine Cover

Enjoy articles like this?

Subscribe to the magazine.

Get access to everything Guns & Ammo has to offer.
Subscribe to the Magazine

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout cartridge was developed to provide greater effectiveness than a 9mm at short and medium ranges when fired from a short-barreled suppressed firearm. Just because the cartridge wasn't designed to go long doesn't mean Rifles & Optics Editor Tom Beckstrand won't take it there, using a large-format pistol, no less. Armed with SIG Sauer's 9-inch-barreled MCX Virtus Pistol loaded with Black Hills' 125-grain TMK ammunition, Beckstrand attempts to ring steel at 600 yards with help from Hornady's 4DOF ballistic calculator in this segment of “Long Range Tech.”

Air Gun Reviews: Why Shoot Airsoft?

Air Gun Reviews: Why Shoot Airsoft?

In this Guns & Ammo TV segment, Gun Tech Editor Richard Nance and Pro-Shooter Jim Tarr discuss the benefits of airsoft training for uniformed professionals and armed citizens alike.

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

At the heart of the rifle is the Model 2020 action which wish designed and built with very tight tolerances thanks to Springfield's technology-driven manufacturing capabilities The stainless steel action features an integral recoil lug, and pairs with a fluted bolt employing dual cocking cams and an enhanced extractor for high pressure loads. The blueprinted and precisely machined action allows Springfield to offer the Model 2020 with .75" MOA accuracy guarantee. Despite being a production rifle, the Model 2020 should rival more expensive custom builds.

Red vs. Green Lasers: Visibility in Bright Light

Red vs. Green Lasers: Visibility in Bright Light

In this segment of “At The Range,” Handgunning Editor Jeremy Stafford and contributor Patrick Sweeney compare the visibility of red and green lasers in outdoor, sunny conditions.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

The Winchester .350 Legend straight-wall cartridge is ideally suited for hunting hogs and deer; here's everything you need to know to make it work for you..350 Legend Cartridge: Everything You Need to Know Rifle

.350 Legend Cartridge: Everything You Need to Know

Tom Beckstrand - April 02, 2019

The Winchester .350 Legend straight-wall cartridge is ideally suited for hunting hogs and...

The Pulsar Thermion XG50 Thermal Riflescope is the first-ever riflescope to combine a BAE sensor, onboard recording, automatic & manual calibration options, multiple color palettes, and manual focus.Pulsar Thermion XG50 Thermal Riflescope - First Look Optics

Pulsar Thermion XG50 Thermal Riflescope - First Look

Guns & Ammo Staff - September 02, 2020

The Pulsar Thermion XG50 Thermal Riflescope is the first-ever riflescope to combine a BAE...

The first in this new family of Springfield Armory rifles is the Model 2020 Waypoint, the result of years of engineering, testing and evaluation, combined with premium grade components found on rifles costing thousands of dollars more.First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle Rifles

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

Guns & Ammo Staff - September 29, 2020

The first in this new family of Springfield Armory rifles is the Model 2020 Waypoint, the...

A guide on how to pair .223 and 5.56 NATO rifle barrel twist rates with bullet weights. Conventional wisdom says slower twist rates wouldn't properly-stabilize a heavy bullet. On the other hand, faster rates could over-stabilize lighter bullets. This is correct in theory, however, modern ballisticians have all but debunked the over-stabilization theory. All things being equal, it is better to have too much twist than not enough.Pairing Barrel Twist Rates with Bullets for .223 and 5.56 NATO How-To

Pairing Barrel Twist Rates with Bullets for .223 and 5.56 NATO

Keith Wood - November 17, 2018

A guide on how to pair .223 and 5.56 NATO rifle barrel twist rates with bullet weights....

See More Trending Articles

More Industry

From the National Shooting Sports Foundation.NSSF Q&A: Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.)

NSSF Q&A: Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.)

National Shooting Sports Foundation - July 23, 2020

From the National Shooting Sports Foundation.

On October 30, 2020, the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) announced that the 2021 SHOT Show, intended to be held January 19-21, 2021, was cancelled. CANCELLED: 2021 SHOT Show in Las Vegas Industry

CANCELLED: 2021 SHOT Show in Las Vegas

Guns & Ammo Staff - November 02, 2020

On October 30, 2020, the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) announced that the 2021...

Perspective from the National Shooting Sports Foundation.NSSF: Modern Sporting Rifles and Today's Voter

NSSF: Modern Sporting Rifles and Today's Voter

Larry Keane - July 20, 2020

Perspective from the National Shooting Sports Foundation.

PolyOne announced its acquisition of the color masterbatch businesses of Clariant and Clariant Chemicals India Ltd., and has implemented a corporate name change. Beginning immediately, PolyOne is now called Avient.PolyOne Announces Clariant Masterbatch Acquisition and Name Change Industry

PolyOne Announces Clariant Masterbatch Acquisition and Name Change

Guns & Ammo Staff - July 16, 2020

PolyOne announced its acquisition of the color masterbatch businesses of Clariant and Clariant...

See More Industry

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Guns & Ammo App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now