Skip to main content

Did Scalia Suggest the Second Amendment Doesn't Protect AR-15s?

Antonin-ScaliaWe have seen the best and worst of what the Internet age can bring. On the bright side, not only are we more informed than ever, but the Internet can even save lives: If there's a weather disaster, kidnapping or other emergency, we are immediately notified.

But on the other hand, the Internet hasn't exactly improved journalistic integrity. What do you get when you take an incensed, politically polarized populace and give everyone access to the Internet? Millions of online stories written by amateur and professional journalists alike, all screaming for your attention, each seeming to make a more over-the-top claim than the last.

Case in point, Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia's remarks on gun control during a rare interview on Fox News Sunday (his answer starts at about the 6:50 mark):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3oxckyicBY


Scalia wrote the majority opinion in the historic D.C. vs. Heller case and, I believe, all he did during the interview was reaffirm the court's decision: The Second Amendment guarantees an individual right to keep and bear arms; and there are possible limitations on that right, but it's up to future courts to decide what those limitations may be.


"What the opinion in Heller said is it will have to be decided in future cases what limitations upon the right to keep and bears arms are permissible," Scalia said. "Some undoubtedly are."

Reporter Chris Wallace asked Scalia point blank whether semi-automatic firearms could be among the limitations.

"We'll see," Scalia said, unwilling to comment one way or another on an issue with no court precedent.

That's the proper answer from a judge who takes his constitutional role seriously. And, if you ask me, there's no real story here. But that's neither a sexy opinion nor one that will win you a seat at the Internet's Nutjob Table.




In an article entitled, "Scalia opens door for gun-control legislation, extends slow burning debate" FoxNews.com makes the direct connection between Scalia's non-statements, the gun control fervor created by the Aurora shooting and NRA opponents like Mayor Michael Bloomberg, co-founder of Mayors Against Illegal Guns.

"His comments also follow those of lawmakers who have called for tougher gun-related laws in the wake of the shootings," the report says. "Most recently New Jersey Sen. Frank Lautenberg and New York Rep. Carolyn McCarthy, Democrats who said Sunday they will introduce legislation this week to 'make it harder for criminals to anonymously stockpile ammunition through the Internet', as was done before the recent tragic shooting in Aurora, Colorado."

Scalia has been taken out of context by both other righties and, of course, left wings, by both amateur bloggers and the professional media, and the entire Scalia controversy is an example of everything that's wrong with the current state of journalism. As pointed out by blogger Sebastian at PAgunblog.com, "The left is saying that Scalia is supporting a right to rocket launchers, and the right is saying he clearly believes we can restrict AR-15s and magazines. I think Justice Scalia is saying no such thing. He is saying it will have to be decided. This is simply fact. There are no tea leaves to be read here."


I couldn't agree more. It's a shame that we are such a divided society that we whip ourselves into a frenzy at the mere mention of a controversial topic. And it's disgraceful that journalists are so willing to play into it. When viewed without bias, the Scalia gun control story is really no story at all. It took sensationalized journalism to invent one.

Let your opinion be heard in the comments below and take our poll on SportsmenVote.com.

Current Magazine Cover

Enjoy articles like this?

Subscribe to the magazine.

Get access to everything Guns & Ammo has to offer.
Subscribe to the Magazine

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

MantisX 10 Elite is a sensor that attaches to the accessory rail or adapter of your handgun, rifle or shotgun.Improve Shooting Fundamentals With MantisX 10 Elite
Accessories

Improve Shooting Fundamentals With MantisX 10 Elite

MantisX 10 Elite is a sensor that attaches to the accessory rail or adapter of your handgun,...

Richard Nance

Guns & Ammo's annual ranking of gun-friendly states. From worst (New York) to best (Arizona), here are the best states for gun owners from data collected in 2020.Best States for Gun Owners (2020)
2nd Amendment

Best States for Gun Owners (2020)

Guns & Ammo's annual ranking of gun-friendly states. From worst (New York) to best (Arizona),...

Keith Wood

Popular Videos

Air Rifle and Pistol Reviews: Full-Auto Fun

Air Rifle and Pistol Reviews: Full-Auto Fun

Gun Tech Editor Richard Nance and Pro-Shooter Jim Tarr head to the range with both .177-caliber airguns to test their aim and demonstrate why the full-auto selector is often called the "giggle switch."

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

Shooting 600 Yards with .300 Blackout

The .300 Blackout cartridge was developed to provide greater effectiveness than a 9mm at short and medium ranges when fired from a short-barreled suppressed firearm. Just because the cartridge wasn't designed to go long doesn't mean Rifles & Optics Editor Tom Beckstrand won't take it there, using a large-format pistol, no less. Armed with SIG Sauer's 9-inch-barreled MCX Virtus Pistol loaded with Black Hills' 125-grain TMK ammunition, Beckstrand attempts to ring steel at 600 yards with help from Hornady's 4DOF ballistic calculator in this segment of “Long Range Tech.”

Which Sight Is Faster - XS Sight Test

Which Sight Is Faster - XS Sight Test

Jeremy Stafford traveled to Gunsite Academy to compare the speed of stock sights against express, three-dot, suppressor-height and red dot sights.

See All Videos

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Guns & Ammo App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Guns & Ammo stories delivered right to your inbox every week.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now