Skip to main content

Big Court Win on Right to Carry

Illinois CapitolOn Dec. 11, 2012, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit handed gun owners — and all freedom-loving Americans — a major victory, striking down the State of Illinois' total ban on carrying firearms outside the home or workplace for protection.

That ruling is a major step forward in the NRA's long-term battle to strengthen constitutional guarantees of the right to self-defense.

The case, Shepard v. Madigan, was brought by Mary E. Shepard, who was seeking to exercise her right to self-defense after suffering a brutal beating — at her church, shockingly — by a violent criminal. The NRA's state affiliate, the Illinois State Rifle Association, was also a plaintiff in the case, which was fully funded by the NRA.

The court's opinion, written by noted jurist Judge Richard Posner, held that the complete ban on right-to-carry in the state of Illinois is inconsistent with the U.S. Supreme Court's interpretation of the Second Amendment in District of Columbia v. Heller and McDonald v. City of Chicago, and therefore unconstitutional.


Ever since those two decisions were handed down, anti-gun activists and governments have argued that because the Supreme Court only struck down bans on handgun possession in the home, the Second Amendment provides no protection anywhere else.  Judge Posner rejected that distinction as "irrational," pointing out that "a Chicagoan is a good deal more likely to be attacked on a sidewalk in a rough neighborhood than in his apartment on the 35th floor of the Park Tower."


While the appeals court invalidated the Illinois carry ban, it gave the Illinois legislature 180 days to craft a new law that complies with the Second Amendment. While that may still be delayed due to appeals, it means that at least in the short term, the Illinois legislature will have to tackle the Right-to-Carry issue. Of course, anti-gun politicians have already attacked the ruling.  Chicago's anti-gun mayor, Rahm Emanuel, called the decision "wrongheaded" and other anti-gun legislators are urging the state to appeal the decision.

It's a fair bet that those anti-gun legislators and anti-gun Gov. Pat Quinn, who recently proposed an "assault weapons" law that would have banned common semi-automatic rifles like the Ruger 10/22, will try to pass the most restrictive carry law possible. That's the same kind of massive legislative resistance that we saw in Washington, D.C., and Chicago when the Supreme Court struck down those cities' laws.

But it's also important to note that in 2011, a majority of the Illinois House voted for a very mainstream Right-to-Carry bill.  That bill only failed due to a parliamentary maneuver by opponents that required the bill to win a super-majority. Needless to say, this year the NRA will strongly support passage of a carry law that fully respects Illinoisans' Second Amendment rights.

Needless to say, the Shepard case isn't the only Right-to-Carry case working its way through the courts. The week before the Seventh Circuit's decision, the Ninth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals heard arguments in the NRA-supported case of Peruta v. County of San Diego and three other cases challenging carry permit laws and policies in California and Hawaii. Unlike Illinois, those states don't completely ban carry, but give local officials arbitrary power to decide whether a permit applicant has a "need" to carry a firearm for self-defense.


Days before those arguments, the Second Circuit federal appeals court upheld New York's similar law, wrongly concluding that the right to bear arms is more limited outside the home and that the state's "proper cause" requirement is "substantially related to New York's interests in public safety and crime prevention." And a month before that, the Fourth Circuit heard arguments in a case testing a similar Maryland law, which had earlier been struck down by a lower federal court.

We don't know yet whether one of these cases might lead the Supreme Court to firmly speak out on the Right-to-Carry issue. For now, though, the Shepard decision makes clear that we're making important steps in the fight to have Second Amendment rights honored as fully as they deserve.

Chris W. Cox is the Executive Director of the National Rifle Association Institute for Legislative Action and serves as the organization's chief lobbyist.  Please give your support to NRA-ILA today.


Current Magazine Cover

Enjoy articles like this?

Subscribe to the magazine.

Get access to everything Guns & Ammo has to offer.
Subscribe to the Magazine

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Trijicon

Trijicon's New Specialized Reflex Optics (SRO)

The Trijicon SRO is specifically designed for pistol use. The wide field of view and clean, crisp dot makes it easy for users to find and track the dot in both target and competitive shooting applications.

Cameras Don

Cameras Don't Lie: Subsonic 9mm vs. .300 Blackout

In this segment of "Cameras Don't Lie," a subsonic-ammo showdown, 9mm vs. .300 Blackout fired from AR rifles.

Which Sight Is Faster - XS Sight Test

Which Sight Is Faster - XS Sight Test

Jeremy Stafford traveled to Gunsite Academy to compare the speed of stock sights against express, three-dot, suppressor-height and red dot sights.

Pocket-Pistol Carry Tips and Tricks

Pocket-Pistol Carry Tips and Tricks

Pocket carry, as a method of concealed carry for a defensive firearm, can be a practical option when done right. This is especially true during the colder months when heavy outer garments can obstruct access to a traditional waistline holster. Former U.S. Navy SEAL Jeff Gonzales, president of Trident Concepts, joins G&A contributor Kimberly Heath-Chudwin to discuss guns, training and gear, including Blackhawk's TecGrip holster that can make pocket carry more successful.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Meet the Wilson Combat Protector: You get the experience of sound design and quality now in a more affordable package.Wilson Combat Protector Review Reviews

Wilson Combat Protector Review

Tom Beckstrand - March 24, 2020

Meet the Wilson Combat Protector: You get the experience of sound design and quality now in a...

The first in this new family of Springfield Armory rifles is the Model 2020 Waypoint, the result of years of engineering, testing and evaluation, combined with premium grade components found on rifles costing thousands of dollars more.First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle Rifles

First Look: Springfield Armory Model 2020 Waypoint Bolt-Action Rifle

Guns & Ammo Staff - September 29, 2020

The first in this new family of Springfield Armory rifles is the Model 2020 Waypoint, the...

Springfield Armory's SAINT Edge Pistol may be the best AR pistol on the market.Springfield Armory SAINT Edge Pistol Review Handguns

Springfield Armory SAINT Edge Pistol Review

James Tarr - April 17, 2019

Springfield Armory's SAINT Edge Pistol may be the best AR pistol on the market.

The one glaring weakness in the .30-­caliber magnum cartridge lineup is best highlighted by examining the requirement around which Hornady designed the .300 PRC; the requirement came from the U.S. Special Operations Command (SOCOM). .300 PRC Review Rifle

.300 PRC Review

Tom Beckstrand - March 12, 2019

The one glaring weakness in the .30-­caliber magnum cartridge lineup is best highlighted by...

See More Trending Articles

More Politics

It's no secret to anyone who is paying attention that gun rights are in the crosshairs of theTop 20 Politicians for Gun Owners 2016 Politics

Top 20 Politicians for Gun Owners 2016

Keith Wood - November 02, 2016

It's no secret to anyone who is paying attention that gun rights are in the crosshairs of the

Gun owners beware of coming attacks on the Second Amendment.Democrats Gain Full Control 2nd Amendment

Democrats Gain Full Control

Keith Wood - January 06, 2021

Gun owners beware of coming attacks on the Second Amendment.

On Sept. 16, 2013, a civilian contractor with some history of mental illness used a valid securityG&A Perspectives: When is a Shooting a 'National Tragedy'? Politics

G&A Perspectives: When is a Shooting a 'National Tragedy'?

Kyle Wintersteen - October 28, 2013

On Sept. 16, 2013, a civilian contractor with some history of mental illness used a valid...

See More Politics

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Guns & Ammo App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now