Most gun owners view our possession of firearms as an insurance policy in itself. A firearm in the nightstand or carried concealed is self-administered insurance against those who could harm us.
But what if the unthinkable happens? If youâ€™re forced to use your firearm in self-defense, what happens in the aftermath of the incident?
We see this scenario play out regularly across the country. A legally armed citizen uses a gun in self-defense, then appears in court to prove that the legal requirements were met to justify using deadly force. When the court rules that the citizen complied with the law and is not guilty of any crime, life just goes on, right?
Itâ€™s not always that simple. Any court case could result in you spending tens of thousands of dollars to protect your freedom and clear your name. Even once youâ€™re cleared of all criminal charges, the family of the deceased might take further action to sue you in civil court for wrongful death. Once a civil trial determines you are not liable for damages, you could still face a pile of legal bills in the process.
With the expansion of concealed carry in the United States, insurance providers are now offering concealed carry and self-defense insurance policies. Since several coverage options are now available from a number of providers, thereâ€™s an abundance of factors to consider when choosing a self-defense insurance plan.
How to Choose the Best Plan
First, consider any coverage you may already be entitled to through your homeownerâ€™s insurance. Most homeownerâ€™s insurance policies have clauses that may either enable or prevent your current plan from covering you in a self-defense scenario on your own property. It is worth speaking with your insurance agent to figure out what kind of coverageâ€”if anyâ€”is included in your current plan.
Second, study the state laws where you reside. Many states have Stand Your Ground laws that protect individuals against civil suits in lawful self-defense scenarios. Generally, these laws make it unlikely that you will face a civil suit when rightfully defending yourself.
If youâ€™re not likely to face a civil suit due to state laws, then it may not make sense to pay a premium for insurance coverage. However, if your stateâ€™s laws donâ€™t favor self-defense scenarios, you may want to consider an insurance plan that covers the costs of civil lawsuits.
Please note that itâ€™s very important to stay abreast of the laws in your state. Legislation is ever-changing, and it bears noting that in the current political climate, there is significant push-back against established Stand Your Ground laws.
Next, consider the varying levels of insurance coverage provided. Most policies offer more than one level of protection. The more you pay monthly or yearly, the greater amount of civil and criminal coverage you may be entitled to during a trial.
It is important to note that, for criminal trials, most plans only offer reimbursement for money spent defending yourself. Several insurance plans will not provide money upfront for a criminal proceeding and will only pay out if you are found not guilty.
However, many plans will cover your legal bills for civil cases up to the plan limit. Itâ€™s also recommended to carefully consider how much coverage you feel you might need based upon where you live. Going to court in one jurisdiction versus another can be a much different experience, and this can lead to vastly different costs.
Itâ€™s likely that if you were ever caught up in a high-profile self-defense case, any of the plans mentioned later in this article would only cover a fraction of your criminal proceedings costs.
The final things to consider when choosing self-defense insurance are any additional features included in the plan. For example, find out whether a plan will cover fees for an expert witness and whether those fees are provided upfront or reimbursed later.
Also, always find out if the plan provides an attorney for you or if it allows you to pick an attorney whom you feel will represent you best. Likewise, determine if the plan covers your family members during a self-defense incident within your home using your firearm.
Some plans may also provide access to networks of resources, such as expert witnesses, for use in your trial.
Do Your Homework
When choosing self-defense insurance, itâ€™s important to research the different plans available and choose one youâ€™re comfortable with that closely fits your needs.
Due to the unique nature of these plans and the sensitive subject matter, thereâ€™s not much in the way of readily accessible information detailing customersâ€™ individual experiences with the various insurance providers.
If you have suggestions for choosing concealed carry insurance, please comment below to help others with this process.
To guide you toward the best coverage options for you, hereâ€™s an overview of several common concealed carry insurance providers:
Cost: $125 per year
Features: Provides a $10,000 fee deposit to your lawyer if you are charged with a felony, $5,000 deposit if charged with a misdemeanor; access to Network-affiliated attorneys and experts; all members get eight educational DVDs
Armed Citizens Legal Defense Network Website
Cost: $165 to $600 annually
Criminal Coverage Offered: $50,000 to $100,000
Civil Coverage Offered: $100,000 to $1,000,000 single overall limit combined with criminal-defense reimbursement
Features: Exclusively endorsed by the NRA
NRA Self-Defense Insurance Website
Cost: $9 to $40 monthly
Criminal Coverage Offered: $10,000 to $50,000
Civil Coverage Offered: $0 to unlimited
Features: Accidental-shooting protection, immediate cash for bail, higher-level coverage offers on-site assistance, gun retrieval/replacement, in-court compensation, psychological support. This plan is offered by Lockton Affinity, LLC, and backed by the NRA Endorsed Insurance.
Second Call Defense Website
Cost: Tied to USCCA membership
Criminal Coverage Offered: $50,000 to $100,000
Civil Coverage Offered: $75,000 to $500,000
Features: Cash for bail, compensation while in court, attorney referrals, immediate criminal attorney retainer
USCCA Shield Website